Synthetic Consumer LabSynthetic Consumer Lab
Back to the studyExperiment 1 / Six scenarios

Who invited, how much was the venue: who should pay?

Can and Elif met on an app. One of them invited and picked the venue, then the bill came. The same 357 people answered “who should pay?” and “what would you do?” for each of six scenarios.

6Scenarios · inviter × venue
357People · the same in every scenario
2Questions · the norm and own behaviour
Finding

“Whoever invites pays” only applies to men.

Even when the woman invited and picked the expensive venue, almost nobody said “the woman should pay”; only 11 of 2,142 answers across the six scenarios did. When the man invites and the venue gets pricier, more people say “the man should pay”; when the woman invites, the answer shifts to splitting.

Q1 / Who should pay?

The inviter or gender?

Share saying “the man should pay”
The man invitedThe woman invited
Coffee300 TL46%Split 54% · The woman should pay 0%41%Split 59% · The woman should pay 0%
Restaurant1,500 TL52%Split 48% · The woman should pay 0%36%Split 64% · The woman should pay 1%
Fine dining5,000 TL60%Split 40% · The woman should pay 0%31%Split 67% · The woman should pay 2%

Each cell shows one scenario: the row gives the venue and total bill, the column shows who invited. The large figure shows the share saying “the man should pay” in that scenario, and the line below shows the other answers. The same 357 people answered all six.

2%In no scenario does the share saying “the woman should pay” exceed this. The result does not change even when she invited and picked the expensive venue.

When the man invites, the share saying “the man should pay” is 46%, at coffee and 60% at fine dining. When the woman invites, at the same venues this share is 41% ve 31% , and the difference goes to splitting. In short, a man who picks the expensive place pays, and a woman who picks it splits.

Men give the “man should pay” answer most often: among male participants the share is 51%, among female participants 37%. The average across six scenarios is 44% .

Q1 / Scenario by scenario

Full distribution for each scenario

Four options, six scenarios. For each venue, the man’s invitation is on the left and the woman’s on the right. The first venue is open; expand the others to compare.

Fine dining · 5,000 TL
The man invited

Single choice · 357 people

  1. The man should pay60% · 213 people
  2. The woman should pay0% · 0 people
  3. They should split it evenly24% · 85 people
  4. Each should pay for their own17% · 59 people
The woman invited

Single choice · 357 people

  1. The man should pay31% · 109 people
  2. The woman should pay2% · 8 people
  3. They should split it evenly43% · 155 people
  4. Each should pay for their own24% · 85 people
Restaurant · 1,500 TL
The man invited

Single choice · 357 people

  1. The man should pay52% · 187 people
  2. The woman should pay0% · 0 people
  3. They should split it evenly38% · 137 people
  4. Each should pay for their own9% · 33 people
The woman invited

Single choice · 357 people

  1. The man should pay36% · 128 people
  2. The woman should pay1% · 2 people
  3. They should split it evenly47% · 168 people
  4. Each should pay for their own17% · 59 people
Coffee · 300 TL
The man invited

Single choice · 357 people

  1. The man should pay46% · 166 people
  2. The woman should pay0% · 0 people
  3. They should split it evenly41% · 145 people
  4. Each should pay for their own13% · 46 people
The woman invited

Single choice · 357 people

  1. The man should pay41% · 147 people
  2. The woman should pay0% · 1 people
  3. They should split it evenly44% · 156 people
  4. Each should pay for their own15% · 53 people
Q2 / What would you do?

The norm is one thing, behaviour another

Here everyone stepped into the shoes of the character of their own gender and said what they would do. The shares below are averages across the six scenarios.

Women
  1. I would pay the whole bill6% · 11 people
  2. I would offer to split84% · 140 people
  3. I would expect the other person to pay10% · 17 people
Men
  1. I would pay the whole bill33% · 62 people
  2. I would offer to split64% · 122 people
  3. I would expect the other person to pay3% · 6 people

Norm and behaviour part ways: most women who say “the man should pay” say they would offer to split themselves. Women’s answers do not change with the venue or the inviter; men’s shift towards paying the whole bill at the expensive venue.

Breakdowns

By gender, age, SES and preference type

The man invited, restaurant 1,500 TL: who should pay?
Gender
GenderPeopleThe man should payThe woman should payThey should split it evenlyEach should pay for their own
Female16744%0%47%8%
Male19059%0%31%10%
Age
AgePeopleThe man should payThe woman should payThey should split it evenlyEach should pay for their own
18–2410750%0%42%7%
25–3413851%0%39%10%
35–4411256%0%34%10%
SES
SESPeopleThe man should payThe woman should payThey should split it evenlyEach should pay for their own
A7559%0%27%15%
B6549%0%45%6%
C110753%0%41%6%
C211049%0%40%11%
Preference type
Preference typePeopleThe man should payThe woman should payThey should split it evenlyEach should pay for their own
Egalitarian13125%0%70%5%
Traditional11466%0%22%12%
Show-oriented11271%0%18%12%
The woman invited, restaurant 1,500 TL: who should pay?
Gender
GenderPeopleThe man should payThe woman should payThey should split it evenlyEach should pay for their own
Female16729%1%54%15%
Male19042%0%41%18%
Age
AgePeopleThe man should payThe woman should payThey should split it evenlyEach should pay for their own
18–2410736%0%49%16%
25–3413835%1%46%18%
35–4411238%1%46%15%
SES
SESPeopleThe man should payThe woman should payThey should split it evenlyEach should pay for their own
A7560%1%36%3%
B6529%2%55%14%
C110726%0%55%19%
C211033%0%42%25%
Preference type
Preference typePeopleThe man should payThe woman should payThey should split it evenlyEach should pay for their own
Egalitarian13113%0%65%22%
Traditional11439%0%41%19%
Show-oriented11259%2%32%7%
The man invited, fine dining 5,000 TL: who should pay?
Gender
GenderPeopleThe man should payThe woman should payThey should split it evenlyEach should pay for their own
Female16757%0%25%17%
Male19062%0%23%16%
Age
AgePeopleThe man should payThe woman should payThey should split it evenlyEach should pay for their own
18–2410767%0%20%13%
25–3413854%0%28%19%
35–4411260%0%23%17%
SES
SESPeopleThe man should payThe woman should payThey should split it evenlyEach should pay for their own
A7556%0%35%9%
B6554%0%28%18%
C110765%0%23%11%
C211060%0%15%25%
Preference type
Preference typePeopleThe man should payThe woman should payThey should split it evenlyEach should pay for their own
Egalitarian13148%0%37%15%
Traditional11469%0%10%21%
Show-oriented11263%0%23%13%
The man invited, restaurant 1,500 TL: what would you do?
Gender
GenderPeopleI would pay the whole billI would offer to splitI would expect the other person to pay
Female1675%83%11%
Male19033%65%2%
Age
AgePeopleI would pay the whole billI would offer to splitI would expect the other person to pay
18–241079%80%10%
25–3413828%67%5%
35–4411221%75%4%
SES
SESPeopleI would pay the whole billI would offer to splitI would expect the other person to pay
A7543%55%3%
B6514%83%3%
C110712%81%7%
C211015%74%11%
Preference type
Preference typePeopleI would pay the whole billI would offer to splitI would expect the other person to pay
Egalitarian13114%79%7%
Traditional11418%78%4%
Show-oriented11229%63%8%

Method and interpretation

Panel

A synthetic panel of 500 people aged 18–44, single or divorced. Age bands were set at 35 / 40 / 25 and gender at 50 / 50; city, education and income were left to their natural distribution. The panel does not represent single people in Turkey; findings rest on differences between segments.

Why SES A–C2?

People in groups D and E answered the price questions inconsistently and most had never been on a first date. All reported shares are based on the 357 people in A–C2; the price gradient by SES uses the full panel.

Scenarios and arms

The six date scenarios and the three behaviours at the bill were asked as separate surveys to the same people. Everyone answered each question once. Differences between scenario cells are changes in the same people’s answers.

To see the detailed breakdowns and the full results, write to [email protected] and we will share them.